So I've decided to have the surgery but now I am trying to decide between allo/autograft. Who here had what and has it worked? I am beyond confused trying to figure out which option is best for me.
The ACL Repair Forum Firsthand accounts of ACL surgery and recovery
About this topic
- Posted by shana 10 months ago. There are 3 posts. The latest reply is from shana.
-
-
Hi Shana. I think you will get lots of different opinions on this issue. Most people feel pretty strongly about it once they make their decision. I tore my ACL in August playing laser tag with my summer camp kids (I've injured it twice before without having it checked out) and am now 7 weeks post ACL/meniscus surgery. I chose allograft for several reasons: Although I'm active, I'm not an athlete. I know 2 people personally who have had excellent results with allograft. I liked the fact that I'd have a quicker recovery. Most importantly, it was what my OS recommended for my situation. Most doctors will specialize or prefer 1 method over the other.
Each method has its pros and cons, so the best thing is to discuss it with your OS and do your own research, decide based on what is best for you. It's a confusing dilemma. Once you decide, go with it, follow the advice of your OS and PT so you can maximize the results no matter which option you choose.
From what I've read, statistically the difference in effectiveness is more of an issue for athletes. If I were an athlete I'd have probably made a different choice. I want to be able to return to my "active" life--able to run, play (not competitively) without worrying about my knee giving out. I like to go to the gym, but mostly cycling and elliptical, which are inline activities, so low risk for knee injury.
By the way, the allograft procedure was no walk in the park! I've always thought I had a pretty high pain tolerance, but this put me to the test! I've had way more invasive surgery and this was MUCH tougher. It's not unbearable, but I think I underestimated how difficult the first couple of weeks would be because I'd read that the allograft was "easier." It probably is...but was still intense! I noticed a substantial improvement after the 2 week point.
Good luck--whatever you choose!
-
Thanks! I much like yourself and do in-line sports and stick to the elliptical and the bike at the gym as well. I would like to take a hike every now and then though. I am going to discuss my options with my doctor but you've given me some good advice.
Reply
You must log in to post.